# Lifecycle Phase 2 Audit

## Scope

Phase 2 introduces a `DeliveryAssessment` type and switches user-facing rendering away from direct `VerifyStatus::EmptyDiff` and `VerifyStatus::HollowOutput` checks.

Files reviewed:

- `src/types.rs`
- `src/types/delivery.rs`
- `src/types/task.rs`
- `src/cmd/show.rs`
- `src/cmd/show_helpers.rs`
- `src/cmd/show_json.rs`
- `src/board.rs`
- `src/cmd/board.rs`
- `src/cmd/tree.rs`
- related tests

## Verdict

Approve with follow-up.

The slice cleanly separates delivery-quality semantics at the type and rendering layers without requiring a schema migration. No blocking regression was found in the touched paths.

## Findings

### No blocking findings in the slice

- `Task::delivery_assessment()` centralizes the mapping from persisted verify-state markers to delivery semantics
- `show`, `show_helpers`, `board`, `tree`, and `show --json` now consume delivery assessment or explicit verify-failure helpers instead of matching no-change semantics directly on `VerifyStatus`
- Regression tests cover the new type mapping plus JSON exposure in `show` and `board`

## Follow-Up

### Delivery assessment is still derived from persisted verify state

This slice intentionally keeps storage compatibility. A later slice should move delivery assessment to its own persisted field so the schema matches the code-level separation.

### Existing repo-wide audit blocker

`aic audit --diff /tmp/phase2-delivery.diff` was blocked again by the repository's existing `cargo clippy -- -D warnings` failure related to duplicate loading of `src/agent/gemini_support.rs`.

## Evidence

- `cargo test delivery_assessment -- --nocapture`
- `cargo test board_json_row_includes_delivery_assessment -- --nocapture`
- `cargo test task_json_includes_delivery_assessment -- --nocapture`
- `git diff --check`
- `rg -n "VerifyStatus::EmptyDiff|VerifyStatus::HollowOutput" src/cmd src/board.rs src/web -g '*.rs'`
- `aic audit --diff /tmp/phase2-delivery.diff`:
  - blocked by existing `cargo clippy -- -D warnings` failure
