# Code Review for aki-stats (Round 2)

## Overview
This second review evaluates the project following the implementation of several optimizations and documentation updates. The project continues to demonstrate high-quality Rust engineering, now with improved performance and clearer behavioral specifications.

## Review Findings

### 1. Specifications and Clarity
*   **Documentation Updates**: The addition of the `# Specifications` section in `src/lib.rs` (and consequently `README.md`) is a significant improvement. It clearly defines the tool's focus on UTF-8 and explicitly mentions that byte counts exclude line terminators. This manages user expectations effectively.
*   **Behavioral Consistency**: The code now perfectly aligns with the documented specifications, making the "non-standard" byte counting a deliberate and well-communicated design choice.

### 2. Performance and Efficiency
*   **Loop Consolidation**: The refactoring of `run_00` into a single pass over characters significantly improves efficiency when multiple statistics are requested. This reduces the overhead of UTF-8 decoding and redundant memory scans.
*   **Optimized ASCII Mapping**: By using `as_bytes()` when only ASCII mapping is required (without char/word counts), the tool maintains high performance for byte-oriented tasks.
*   **Fixed-Size Array**: The transition of `StatsAscii` from `Vec<u64>` to `[u64; 128]` successfully eliminates heap allocation for this component. This is a more idiomatic use of Rust for fixed-domain data and slightly reduces memory management overhead.

### 3. Architecture and Maintainability
*   **I/O and Configuration**: The architecture remains robust. The use of `runnel` continues to provide excellent flexibility for stream management.
*   **Boilerplate Management**: The `xtask` integration for CLI documentation remains a strong point of the project's maintenance strategy.
*   **Updated Changelog**: The `CHANGELOG.md` correctly reflects the recent "Unreleased" changes, maintaining a clear audit trail for the project's evolution.

### 4. Code Style and Idioms
*   **Modern Rust Practices**: The code utilizes modern Rust features effectively (e.g., `unwrap_or(&0)` on iterators, `copied()` for options).
*   **Clean Abstractions**: The `StatsAscii` struct and its implementation are now simpler and more focused.

## Recommendations
The project is currently in excellent shape. Future considerations could include:
1.  **SIMD Acceleration**: For extremely large files, consider using SIMD-accelerated libraries (like `memchr`) for whitespace detection if word counting becomes a bottleneck, although the current implementation is likely sufficient for most use cases.
2.  **Extended Unicode Support**: Periodically review the whitespace logic to ensure it remains compliant with the intended Unicode standard versions as the Rust compiler and standard library evolve.

## Conclusion
The recent updates have successfully addressed previous observations regarding performance and documentation. `aki-stats` is a specialized, high-performance tool with a clear mission and solid implementation.

---
Review Date: 2026-05-19
Reviewer: Gemini CLI Agent
