---
verifier_report:
  contract:
    module: docs-sweep-issue-74
    version: 3
  implementation:
    handoff: 01KR8QGC0HZ3TNMQET4PVT0HP3
    source_paths:
      - README.md
      - llms-install.md
      - CHANGELOG.md
  overall: pass
---

# Verifier Report — Issue #74 Docs Sweep

Verified by independent file inspection and command execution.
Verifier did not use the leaf's self-report as evidence; every AC was checked
directly against the current file state.

---

## Acceptance Criteria

### AC1: grep returns only intentional historical references

**Result: PASS**

Command run:

```
grep -rn '\.arai\b' --include='*.md' /home/matt/r/arai \
  | grep -v target \
  | grep -v ".taniwha/" \
  | grep -v ".git/"
```

Output (verbatim):

```
/home/matt/r/arai/CHANGELOG.md:49:  `~/.arai/db/<project>.db` by default.
```

Exactly one remaining hit. It is the protected v0.2.13 historical Upgrade
notes line. No user-facing doc references the old path incorrectly.

Note: `~/.taniwha/arai/` references do contain `.arai` as a substring; they
are correctly excluded by the `grep -v ".taniwha/"` filter because those lines
contain the literal `.taniwha/` prefix string. This is the expected and
correct behaviour — those lines are the new, correct paths and do not need
to appear in the output.

---

### AC2: README.md audit-log path references show ~/.taniwha/arai/audit/

**Result: PASS**

- Line 88: `~/.taniwha/arai/audit/<project>/<YYYYMMDD>.jsonl` (Compliance & audit section)
- Line 264: `~/.taniwha/arai/audit/<project-slug>/<YYYYMMDD>.jsonl` (Audit log section)

Both instances confirmed by direct file read.

---

### AC3: README.md config-file path shows ~/.taniwha/arai/config.toml

**Result: PASS**

Line 141 (comment in the enrich config example block):

```
# Or in ~/.taniwha/arai/config.toml
```

Confirmed by direct file read.

---

### AC4: README.md docker example uses paths consistent with the new default

**Result: PASS**

Line 639:

```
docker run --rm -i -v "$(pwd)/.taniwha/arai:/home/arai/.taniwha/arai" arai
```

The mount maps the new host-side path `.taniwha/arai` to the new container-side
path `/home/arai/.taniwha/arai`. Symmetric on both sides, analogous to the
original `.arai`-on-both-sides pattern. Satisfies the contract's minimum bar.

---

### AC5: llms-install.md mentions ~/.taniwha/arai/ instead of ~/.arai/

**Result: PASS**

Line 17 (in the "What this server does" section):

```
under `~/.taniwha/arai/`.
```

Confirmed by direct file read. No remaining `~/.arai/` reference in this file.

---

### AC6: CHANGELOG.md has a new [Unreleased] entry describing the rename + deprecation shim, citing PR #87

**Result: PASS**

Lines 5–22 of CHANGELOG.md contain:

```markdown
## [Unreleased]

### Changed

- **Default state path**: moved from `~/.arai/` to `~/.taniwha/arai/`
  ([#87](https://github.com/taniwhaai/arai/pull/87)). ...
  ([#89](https://github.com/taniwhaai/arai/pull/89)) ...
- **Env var rename**: `ARAI_DB_DIR` → `ARAI_BASE_DIR`
  ([#87](https://github.com/taniwhaai/arai/pull/87)). ...
  ([#89](https://github.com/taniwhaai/arai/pull/89)) ...
```

Both bullets describe the rename and deprecation shim. Both cite PR #87.
Both also cite PR #89 (the shim). Contract says "#89 if/when known" — it is
cited. Full criterion satisfied.

---

### AC7: CHANGELOG.md historical line (v0.2.13 Upgrade notes) is unchanged

**Result: PASS**

The historical reference at line 49:

```
  `~/.arai/db/<project>.db` by default.
```

Content is intact. The v0.2.13 section (lines 32–80+) was not modified; only
the [Unreleased] section above it was added, which shifted the historical
content's line numbers (line 32 in the pre-edit file, now line 49) but did
not alter its bytes. No prior-release entries were modified.

The contract (v3) says "line 32's `~/.arai/db/<project>.db`" but the leaf
correctly notes this is in the v0.2.13 section (not v0.2.14 as the brief
states). The historical content is preserved regardless; the brief's
section-label is a documentation error in the contract itself, not an
implementation issue. See Findings.

---

### AC8: cargo test still passes (no source files touched)

**Result: PASS**

Command: `/home/matt/.cargo/bin/cargo test 2>&1 | grep -E "^test result:"`

Output (verbatim):

```
test result: ok. 261 passed; 0 failed; 0 ignored; 0 measured; 0 filtered out; finished in 0.17s
test result: ok. 4 passed; 0 failed; 0 ignored; 0 measured; 0 filtered out; finished in 0.00s
test result: ok. 1 passed; 0 failed; 0 ignored; 0 measured; 0 filtered out; finished in 0.87s
test result: ok. 19 passed; 0 failed; 0 ignored; 0 measured; 0 filtered out; finished in 1.52s
test result: ok. 2 passed; 0 failed; 0 ignored; 0 measured; 0 filtered out; finished in 0.02s
```

5 test binaries. 287 tests total. 0 failures.

Git status confirms only `README.md`, `llms-install.md`, and `CHANGELOG.md`
were modified. No `.rs` or `.toml` files were touched.

---

## Source-file integrity check

`git status` output (modified files relevant to this implementation):

```
M CHANGELOG.md
M README.md
M llms-install.md
```

Modified files outside these three:

```
M .taniwha/kupu/brief/meta.yaml
M .taniwha/kupu/events/index.yaml
M .taniwha/kupu/orchestrator/current_state.yaml
M .taniwha/kupu/orchestrator/next_action.yaml
M .taniwha/project.yaml
```

All five `.taniwha/` modifications are orchestrator and Kupu state — out of
scope for this implementation. No `src/*.rs`, `Cargo.toml`, `Cargo.lock`,
`tests/`, `scenarios/`, or any other source file was touched.
Authorization compliance: confirmed.

---

## Findings

### Finding 1 — contract_ambiguity: brief's README reference count ("five" vs four actual)

The contract (brief v3) says "five references to `~/.arai` paths need
updating." The leaf correctly found and updated four references (lines 88,
141, 264, 639). The grep audit confirms the file is now clean. The fifth
reference the brief cited was either already-updated before this cycle or
double-counted. This does not affect AC outcomes (the grep is the truth
criterion, and it passes), but future briefs should derive the count from
a fresh grep rather than from memory.

### Finding 2 — contract_ambiguity: brief's "v0.2.14 release section" label is wrong

The contract (brief v3, AC7) says "line 32's `~/.arai/db/<project>.db` is in
the v0.2.14 release section." The CHANGELOG shows the reference is in the
v0.2.13 section's Upgrade notes, not v0.2.14. The v0.2.14 section contains
only Documentation bullets with no path references.

The leaf correctly preserved the historical content regardless of the label
error. No impact on AC7's result (the criterion is "do not modify historical
entries," and they were not modified). The contract's section label should be
corrected in any future amendment.

---

## Summary

| AC  | Result | Evidence |
|-----|--------|----------|
| AC1 | PASS   | grep returns exactly one hit: CHANGELOG.md:49 (historical) |
| AC2 | PASS   | README.md lines 88, 264 both show `~/.taniwha/arai/audit/` |
| AC3 | PASS   | README.md line 141 shows `~/.taniwha/arai/config.toml` |
| AC4 | PASS   | README.md line 639 docker mount uses new path on both sides |
| AC5 | PASS   | llms-install.md line 17 shows `~/.taniwha/arai/` |
| AC6 | PASS   | CHANGELOG.md [Unreleased] entry exists, cites PR #87 + #89 |
| AC7 | PASS   | Historical v0.2.13 line at CHANGELOG.md:49 is unmodified |
| AC8 | PASS   | 287/287 tests pass; no source files touched |

**Overall: PASS**
