<!-- START doctoc generated TOC please keep comment here to allow auto update -->
<!-- DON'T EDIT THIS SECTION, INSTEAD RE-RUN doctoc TO UPDATE -->
**Table of Contents**

- [Academic Peer Review Workflow Package — Updated Findings](#academic-peer-review-workflow-package--updated-findings)

<!-- END doctoc generated TOC please keep comment here to allow auto update -->

## Academic Peer Review Workflow Package — Updated Findings

- Registry entry: `marketplace/registry/index.json` lists `academic-peer-review-workflow` v1.0.0, category `academic-workflow`, dependency `academic-paper-lifecycle`, production_ready currently `false`, download URL points to repo zip, checksum present, downloads/stars set to 0.
- Package payload now present under `marketplace/packages/academic-peer-review-workflow/`:
  - `README.md`, `USAGE.md`
  - `workflows/peer_review.workflow.json` with variables, required files, stages, artifacts, determinism notes, and pre-run hook
  - Templates: `templates/reviewer-template.rdf`, `templates/response-template.md`
  - Schema: `data/review-schema.ttl`
  - Hook: `hooks/validate.sh` checks required files and required stages
  - Fixtures: `paper.rdf`, `reviewers.json`; `output/` mapped for generated artifacts
- Manifest highlights (from `package.toml`):
  - Features: multi-reviewer coordination, comment tracking, author responses, revision tracking, decision workflow, deadlines, consensus, COI handling, RDF storage, git integration, summaries.
  - Variables: `paper_id` (required), `deadline` (required, YYYY-MM-DD), `managing_editor` (required), `num_reviewers` (default 3).
  - Stages: initial-submission → editorial-screening → reviewer-assignment → review-period → decision-compilation → decision-communication → author-revision → re-review → final-decision.
- Usability status (post-fix):
  - Installable with included assets; validation hook enforces required inputs/stages.
  - Registry production flag still `false`; should be flipped after end-to-end validation and checksum refresh.
- Recommended follow-ups:
  1) Add sample `paper.rdf` and `reviewers.json` fixtures for quickstart validation.
  2) Run `ggen marketplace validate --package_id academic-peer-review-workflow` and update registry `production_ready` and `checksum` once validated.
  3) (Optional) Add workflow example event log and golden outputs for determinism checks.



