# Audit Result: ggen workflow analyze
# Command: ggen workflow analyze
# Category: workflow
# Date: 2024-12-14

command: "ggen workflow analyze"
version_tested: "4.0.0"
date: "2024-12-14"
tester: "claude-code"

functional_correctness:
  executes: false             # Crashes without required --workflow_file argument
  help_works: true            # --help displays documentation
  happy_path: false           # Requires external workflow.json file (cannot test standalone)
  error_handling: true        # Clear error messages for missing arguments
  exit_codes: true            # Proper exit codes (0/1)

agent_score: 28
agent_breakdown:
  parseable_output: 3         # Text-only output, no JSON format option
  error_messages: 10          # Good error messages identifying missing --workflow_file
  idempotency: 8              # Read-only operation, idempotent
  progress_feedback: 2        # Silent operation (no progress indication)
  dry_run: 0                  # No dry-run support
  documentation: 3            # Help text present but minimal inline examples
  exit_codes: 2               # Basic exit codes (0/1 only)

avatar_notes:
  claude_code: "Cannot orchestrate without input file setup; no JSON output limits usefulness; requires external file handling"
  cursor_ai: "Help text clear but limited; requires file context to test; not practical for inline IDE usage"
  copilot: "Requires file setup; limited pattern examples in help text; difficult for completion-based learning"
  aider: "Requires pre-existing workflow file; cannot automate safely without file management; text output requires parsing"
  devin: "File dependency blocks autonomous execution; would need file creation/management logic first"
  openhands: "Text output requires manual parsing; needs file setup in workspace; difficult for standalone usage"
  windsurf: "IDE integration challenging due to file dependency; text output not IDE-friendly; requires external file"

maturity_level: "L1"
maturity_blockers:
  - "File-dependent execution blocks autonomous usage (L1 blocker)"
  - "No JSON output format available (blocks L2+)"
  - "Cannot execute standalone without external file (blocks agent orchestration)"

evidence_files:
  - workflow-analyze-help.log
  - workflow-analyze-happy-path.log
  - workflow-analyze-error.log

recommendations:
  - priority: "P1"
    description: "Add --output-format json for structured output compatible with agent orchestration"
    effort: "medium"
    impact: "high"
  - priority: "P1"
    description: "Support --workflow-json flag to accept JSON via stdin, reducing file dependency"
    effort: "low"
    impact: "high"
  - priority: "P2"
    description: "Add progress indicators (--progress flag) for large workflow analyses"
    effort: "medium"
    impact: "medium"
  - priority: "P2"
    description: "Implement --dry-run to preview analysis without side effects"
    effort: "low"
    impact: "medium"

jtbd: |
  When a developer needs to understand workflow execution patterns, I need to analyze
  the workflow structure and identify bottlenecks, so that I can optimize the workflow
  for better performance and maintainability.
