# Audit Result: ggen workflow init
# Schema: ../../contracts/audit-result.schema.yaml

command: "ggen workflow init"
version_tested: "4.0.0"
date: "2024-12-14"
tester: "claude-code"

functional_correctness:
  executes: false         # Fails with "unexpected argument '--type' found" error
  help_works: true        # --help displays command documentation
  happy_path: false       # Help text shows --type but command rejects it
  error_handling: true    # Good error messages identifying unexpected arguments
  exit_codes: true        # Proper exit codes (0/1)

agent_score: 31
agent_breakdown:
  parseable_output: 2     # Text output only, no JSON option
  error_messages: 12      # Clear error identifying unexpected --type argument
  idempotency: 8          # Would be idempotent if executed successfully
  progress_feedback: 2    # Silent operation
  dry_run: 0              # No --dry-run option
  documentation: 5        # Help text mentions --type but command doesn't support it
  exit_codes: 2           # Basic exit codes (0/1)

avatar_notes:
  claude_code: "Documentation-implementation mismatch (--type in help but not accepted); blocks orchestration"
  cursor_ai: "Help text suggests --type parameter but command rejects it; confusing for learning"
  copilot: "Inconsistent help/implementation; tab completion would fail; difficult to learn pattern"
  aider: "Help documentation contradicts actual behavior; risk of failed automated execution"
  devin: "--type parameter advertised in help but not implemented; blocks autonomous execution"
  openhands: "Documentation mismatch creates confusion; would need trial-and-error to find correct syntax"
  windsurf: "IDE help shows --type but command rejects it; poor developer experience"

maturity_level: "L0"
maturity_blockers:
  - "CRITICAL: Help documentation contradicts implementation (shows --type but command rejects it)"
  - "No JSON output format"
  - "Command crashes on documented parameter --type"

evidence_files:
  - workflow-init-help.log
  - workflow-init-noargs.log

recommendations:
  - priority: "P1"
    description: "URGENT: Fix help documentation or implement missing --type parameter"
    effort: "high"
    impact: "high"
  - priority: "P1"
    description: "Add --output-format json for structured initialization output"
    effort: "medium"
    impact: "high"
  - priority: "P2"
    description: "Add --dry-run flag to preview workflow structure without file creation"
    effort: "low"
    impact: "medium"
