<!-- START doctoc generated TOC please keep comment here to allow auto update -->
<!-- DON'T EDIT THIS SECTION, INSTEAD RE-RUN doctoc TO UPDATE -->
**Table of Contents**

- [Task Orchestrator - Investigation Findings](#task-orchestrator---investigation-findings)
  - [Executive Summary](#executive-summary)
  - [Phase 1: Analysis Complete](#phase-1-analysis-complete)
    - [What Was Expected](#what-was-expected)
    - [What Was Actually Found](#what-was-actually-found)
    - [Test Failure Evidence](#test-failure-evidence)
    - [Files Analyzed](#files-analyzed)
  - [Critical Questions for User](#critical-questions-for-user)
    - [Option A: Add OTEL Integration to clap-noun-verb](#option-a-add-otel-integration-to-clap-noun-verb)
    - [Option B: Fix Template Command Registration](#option-b-fix-template-command-registration)
    - [Option C: Both A and B](#option-c-both-a-and-b)
  - [Recommended Next Steps (Pending Clarification)](#recommended-next-steps-pending-clarification)
    - [If Option B (Fix Template Command):](#if-option-b-fix-template-command)
    - [If Option A (Add OTEL):](#if-option-a-add-otel)
  - [Orchestrator Status](#orchestrator-status)
  - [Agent Deployment Readiness](#agent-deployment-readiness)
  - [Technical Context](#technical-context)
    - [Current clap-noun-verb Implementation](#current-clap-noun-verb-implementation)
    - [What EXISTS](#what-exists)
    - [What's MISSING](#whats-missing)
  - [Lessons Learned (Preliminary)](#lessons-learned-preliminary)

<!-- END doctoc generated TOC please keep comment here to allow auto update -->

# Task Orchestrator - Investigation Findings

**Date**: 2025-11-20
**Orchestrator**: Task Orchestrator Agent (Hive Mind)
**Session ID**: swarm-clap-noun-verb-otel-fixes

## Executive Summary

Investigation revealed NO OpenTelemetry (OTEL) integration issues in clap-noun-verb code. The actual problem is that clap-noun-verb integration tests are failing due to missing `template` command registration in the ggen CLI.

## Phase 1: Analysis Complete

### What Was Expected
Based on initial task request: "systematic clap-noun-verb OTEL fixes coordination"
- Expected: OpenTelemetry Span API issues
- Expected: Tracing integration problems
- Expected: OTEL dependency issues

### What Was Actually Found
1. **No OTEL Integration in clap-noun-verb code**
   - Zero references to `opentelemetry`, `tracing`, `span`, or `OTEL` in `/Users/sac/ggen/crates/ggen-cli/src/conventions/presets/clap_noun_verb.rs`
   - No OTEL imports or usage patterns

2. **Actual Problem: Missing Template Command**
   - 15 of 21 tests failing in `clap_noun_verb_integration.rs`
   - Root cause: `ggen template` command not registered/found
   - Test error: Command execution fails with "unrecognized subcommand" or similar

### Test Failure Evidence
```
test result: FAILED. 6 passed; 15 failed; 0 ignored; 0 measured; 0 filtered out

Failed tests:
- test_ggen_help_shows_template_noun (expects 'template' in --help)
- test_template_help_shows_all_verbs (expects template subcommands)
- test_template_list_executes_successfully (template list fails)
- test_template_lint_help_shows_arguments (template lint fails)
- test_template_generate_verb_auto_discovery (template generate fails)
- ... and 10 more
```

### Files Analyzed
- `/Users/sac/ggen/crates/ggen-cli/src/conventions/presets/clap_noun_verb.rs` (54 lines, no OTEL)
- `/Users/sac/ggen/crates/ggen-cli/tests/clap_noun_verb_integration.rs` (876 lines, comprehensive tests)
- `/Users/sac/ggen/Cargo.toml` (workspace manifest with OTEL deps at workspace level)
- `/Users/sac/ggen/templates/clap-noun-verb-360/*.tmpl` (335 template files found)

## Critical Questions for User

**Before proceeding, the Task Orchestrator requires clarification:**

### Option A: Add OTEL Integration to clap-noun-verb
If the task is to ADD OpenTelemetry instrumentation to clap-noun-verb:
- Where should spans be created? (command entry/exit, template rendering, etc.)
- What span attributes are required?
- Should we follow the Span API pattern from other subsystems?
- Performance impact tolerance?

### Option B: Fix Template Command Registration
If the task is to fix the failing clap-noun-verb tests:
- Implement missing `template` command in ggen CLI
- Register template subcommands (list, new, show, generate, lint)
- Make all 21 tests pass
- No OTEL integration needed

### Option C: Both A and B
If both are required:
- First fix template command registration (foundation)
- Then add OTEL instrumentation (observability layer)

## Recommended Next Steps (Pending Clarification)

### If Option B (Fix Template Command):
1. **Code Analyzer Agent**: Review CLI command registration patterns
2. **System Architect Agent**: Design template command structure
3. **Coder Agent**: Implement template command and subcommands
4. **Tester Agent**: Verify all 21 tests pass
5. **Production Validator**: Ensure no regressions

### If Option A (Add OTEL):
1. **Production Validator Agent**: Define OTEL span strategy for clap-noun-verb
2. **System Architect Agent**: Design instrumentation points
3. **Coder Agent**: Add tracing spans with proper attributes
4. **Tester Agent**: Create span verification tests
5. **Performance Benchmarker**: Verify no performance degradation

## Orchestrator Status

**Current State**: ⚠️ BLOCKED - Awaiting user clarification
- Analysis phase: ✅ COMPLETE
- Design phase: ⏸️ PAUSED
- Implementation phase: ⏸️ PENDING
- Validation phase: ⏸️ PENDING

**Andon Signals**:
- 🟡 YELLOW: 15 test failures (not compiler errors, but test infrastructure issues)
- 🟢 GREEN: No compiler errors
- 🟢 GREEN: clap_noun_verb.rs module compiles cleanly

## Agent Deployment Readiness

All agents are ready for deployment pending direction:
- ✅ production-validator: Ready
- ✅ code-analyzer: Ready
- ✅ system-architect: Ready
- ✅ coder: Ready
- ✅ tester: Ready
- ✅ performance-benchmarker: Ready

## Technical Context

### Current clap-noun-verb Implementation
- **File**: `crates/ggen-cli/src/conventions/presets/clap_noun_verb.rs`
- **Purpose**: Convention preset for generating clap noun-verb CLI structures
- **Functionality**:
  - Creates directory structure (.ggen/rdf, .ggen/templates, src/cmds, src/domain)
  - Writes convention config and RDF files
  - Provides template scaffolding
- **Size**: 88 lines (small, focused module)
- **Tests**: 1 unit test (structure creation) + 21 integration tests (15 failing)

### What EXISTS
- ✅ 335 template files in `/templates/clap-noun-verb-360/`
- ✅ clap-noun-verb-macros dependency in workspace
- ✅ Comprehensive integration test suite
- ✅ RDF/TTL specification support
- ✅ Template rendering with Tera

### What's MISSING
- ❌ `template` command registration in ggen CLI
- ❌ Template subcommand implementations (list, new, show, generate, lint)
- ❌ Command auto-discovery for template noun
- ❌ OpenTelemetry instrumentation (if that's the actual goal)

## Lessons Learned (Preliminary)

1. **Clarify Task Scope Early**: "OTEL fixes" in task name didn't match actual problem
2. **Investigate Before Acting**: Avoided wasting effort on wrong problem
3. **80/20 Validation**: Quick grep/search prevented multi-hour wild goose chase

---

**Orchestrator Decision**: HOLDING for user clarification before agent deployment.

**Next Message Should Contain**:
- User's choice: Option A, B, or C
- If Option A: Span strategy and instrumentation requirements
- If Option B: Confirmation to fix template command
- If Option C: Priority ordering

**Estimated Effort**:
- Option A (Add OTEL): 2-3 hours (6 agents, design + implementation + testing)
- Option B (Fix Template Cmd): 1-2 hours (4 agents, implement + test)
- Option C (Both): 3-4 hours (sequential: B then A)
