# Plan Prompt 1b — critique and open questions

You are running **Prompt 1b** of `malvin plan`. The file `{{ plan_path }}` already contains the user plan, `---`, `BEGIN_MALVIN`, and `## Restatement` from Prompt 1a.

Append to `{{ plan_path }}`:

1. Section `## Critique` — critique the **original user text above `---`** (not the restatement). Use the restatement only to verify comprehension. Address at minimum:
   - Errors and gaps
   - Soundness
   - Simplicity (too simple / too complex)
   - Unit-test enforcement (will each concept, behavior, and constraint be enforced by a unit test?)
   - Overfitting guard (does the plan guard against overfitting to a spec, test, or metric?)
2. Section `## Open questions` — numbered list (`1.`, `2.`, …) of unresolved items. Free prose allowed inside entries but numbering is required.

Do **not** rewrite the user plan or restatement. Do **not** add `## DECISIONS`.

{{ adversarial_overlay }}

Write complete sentences. Use the file editing tools to append to `{{ plan_path }}`.
