# TICKET-PMAT-5035: Dogfood PMAT on Itself

**Status**: GREEN
**Priority**: P1
**Complexity**: 3
**Estimated Time**: 45 minutes
**Dependencies**: TICKET-PMAT-5030, TICKET-PMAT-5031, TICKET-PMAT-5032, TICKET-PMAT-5033, TICKET-PMAT-5034
**Sprint**: Sprint 19 - CLI Integration & Dogfooding

## Objective

Use PMAT's own CLI commands on the PMAT project itself to validate that the tools work correctly, provide value, and identify any issues or improvements needed. This is "eating our own dog food" - using our own tools in production.

## Success Criteria

- [ ] `pmat maintain roadmap --health` shows accurate sprint progress
- [ ] `pmat maintain roadmap --validate` passes with no errors
- [ ] `pmat maintain health` runs successfully and reports project health
- [ ] `pmat hooks install` successfully installs pre-commit hooks
- [ ] `pmat hooks verify` confirms hooks work correctly
- [ ] Document any issues or improvements discovered
- [ ] Create dogfooding report with findings

## Current State

**Available Commands:**
- `pmat maintain roadmap` - Roadmap validation and health
- `pmat maintain health` - Project health checks
- `pmat hooks install/status/verify` - Git hooks management
- `pmat scaffold agent/wasm` - Project scaffolding
- `pmat quality-gates` - Quality gate enforcement

**What We'll Test:**
- Roadmap accuracy and ticket synchronization
- Project health metrics (build, tests, coverage)
- Hook installation and verification
- Quality gate integration

## Test Plan

### Phase 1: Roadmap Maintenance

```bash
# Show roadmap health report
pmat maintain roadmap --health

# Validate roadmap structure
pmat maintain roadmap --validate

# Check if any tickets need status updates
pmat maintain roadmap --fix --dry-run

# Apply fixes if needed
pmat maintain roadmap --fix
```

**Expected Results:**
- Sprint 19 shows 5/7 tickets complete (71%)
- All completed tickets (5030-5034) show GREEN status
- No validation errors
- No checkbox inconsistencies

### Phase 2: Project Health Check

```bash
# Run all health checks
pmat maintain health

# Check specific aspects
pmat maintain health --check-build
pmat maintain health --check-tests
pmat maintain health --check-coverage

# Get JSON output for CI
pmat maintain health --format json
```

**Expected Results:**
- Build: PASS (project compiles)
- Tests: PASS or WARN (some tests ignored)
- Coverage: SKIP or WARN (llvm-cov may not be available)
- Complexity: SKIP (future integration)
- SATD: SKIP (future integration)

### Phase 3: Hooks Installation

```bash
# Check current hook status
pmat hooks status

# Install pre-commit hooks
pmat hooks install --backup

# Verify hooks work
pmat hooks verify

# Check status again
pmat hooks status
```

**Expected Results:**
- Hooks install successfully
- Backup created if existing hook present
- Hook is executable
- Verify passes without errors
- Status shows PMAT-managed hook installed

### Phase 4: Quality Gates (Existing)

```bash
# Run quality gates
pmat quality-gates

# Generate report
pmat quality-gates --report

# Check specific gates
pmat quality-gates init --force
pmat quality-gates validate
pmat quality-gates show
```

**Expected Results:**
- Quality gates run successfully
- Configuration valid
- Gates enforced correctly

## Findings Documentation

Create `docs/dogfooding/SPRINT-19-FINDINGS.md` with:

### Structure

```markdown
# Sprint 19 Dogfooding Findings

**Date**: 2025-10-05
**Sprint**: Sprint 19 - CLI Integration & Dogfooding
**Commands Tested**: maintain roadmap, maintain health, hooks

## Executive Summary

[Brief summary of results]

## Commands Tested

### 1. pmat maintain roadmap

**Command**: `pmat maintain roadmap --health`
**Result**: [PASS/FAIL/WARN]
**Output**:
```
[Actual output]
```

**Findings**:
- ✅ What worked well
- ⚠️ Issues discovered
- 💡 Improvements suggested

### 2. pmat maintain health

**Command**: `pmat maintain health`
**Result**: [PASS/FAIL/WARN]
**Output**:
```
[Actual output]
```

**Findings**:
- ✅ What worked well
- ⚠️ Issues discovered
- 💡 Improvements suggested

### 3. pmat hooks install

**Command**: `pmat hooks install`
**Result**: [PASS/FAIL/WARN]
**Output**:
```
[Actual output]
```

**Findings**:
- ✅ What worked well
- ⚠️ Issues discovered
- 💡 Improvements suggested

## Overall Assessment

### What Worked Well
1. [Success 1]
2. [Success 2]

### Issues Discovered
1. [Issue 1] - [Severity: HIGH/MEDIUM/LOW]
2. [Issue 2] - [Severity: HIGH/MEDIUM/LOW]

### Improvements Suggested
1. [Improvement 1] - [Priority: P0/P1/P2]
2. [Improvement 2] - [Priority: P0/P1/P2]

## Follow-up Actions

### Immediate (Sprint 19)
- [ ] [Action 1]
- [ ] [Action 2]

### Future Sprints
- [ ] [Action 3]
- [ ] [Action 4]

## Metrics

- Commands tested: X
- Commands passed: Y
- Issues found: Z
- Time spent: N minutes

## Conclusion

[Overall conclusion about Sprint 19 CLI integration]
```

## Implementation Steps

### Step 1: Test Roadmap Commands

Run and document:
1. `pmat maintain roadmap --health`
2. `pmat maintain roadmap --validate`
3. `pmat maintain roadmap --fix --dry-run`

### Step 2: Test Health Commands

Run and document:
1. `pmat maintain health`
2. `pmat maintain health --format json`
3. `pmat maintain health --format yaml`

### Step 3: Test Hooks Commands

Run and document:
1. `pmat hooks status`
2. `pmat hooks install --backup`
3. `pmat hooks verify`

### Step 4: Create Findings Report

Document all results in `docs/dogfooding/SPRINT-19-FINDINGS.md`

### Step 5: Update Roadmap

Mark ticket complete and update any issues discovered

## Complexity Analysis

This is primarily a testing and documentation task:
- No new code written
- Focus on validation and discovery
- Documentation of findings

## Files to Create

### New Files
- `docs/dogfooding/SPRINT-19-FINDINGS.md` - Dogfooding report

### Modified Files
- `ROADMAP.md` - Mark ticket complete
- Potentially create follow-up tickets based on findings

## Risk Assessment

**Low Risk:**
- Testing existing functionality
- No code changes required
- Documentation only

**Mitigation:**
- Document all findings clearly
- Create tickets for any issues found
- Prioritize critical issues

## Notes

Dogfooding is critical for:

**Quality Validation:**
- Ensures tools work in real-world scenarios
- Catches edge cases and usability issues
- Validates design decisions

**User Experience:**
- Tests actual developer workflow
- Identifies friction points
- Validates documentation accuracy

**Continuous Improvement:**
- Discovers features we're missing
- Identifies areas for enhancement
- Validates priorities

**Expected Outcomes:**
1. Confidence that Sprint 19 tools work correctly
2. List of improvements for future sprints
3. Documentation of real-world usage
4. Validation of design decisions

**Integration:**
- Tests all Sprint 19 commands together
- Validates complete workflow
- Ensures commands work in harmony

**TDD Cycle Duration**: Estimated 45 minutes for testing and documentation
