---
phase: 25-loadtest-config-upload
verified: 2026-02-28T16:00:00Z
status: passed
score: 8/8 must-haves verified
re_verification: false
gaps: []
human_verification:
  - test: "Run `cargo pmcp loadtest upload --server-id test123 /path/to/bad.toml` with an invalid TOML file"
    expected: "Command prints a validation error with actionable fix instructions BEFORE any OAuth prompt appears"
    why_human: "Requires a real terminal session; automated checks confirm the code path exists and error messages are present but cannot execute a live CLI invocation"
  - test: "Run `cargo pmcp loadtest upload --server-id test123 loadtest.toml` against a real pmcp.run account"
    expected: "Successful upload prints config ID, version, dashboard URL, and 'Next steps:' guidance"
    why_human: "Requires live pmcp.run credentials and an active server-id; GraphQL mutation cannot be tested without the network endpoint"
---

# Phase 25: Loadtest Config Upload — Verification Report

**Phase Goal:** Users can validate a loadtest TOML config locally and upload it to pmcp.run for remote execution
**Verified:** 2026-02-28T16:00:00Z
**Status:** PASSED
**Re-verification:** No — initial verification

---

## Goal Achievement

### Observable Truths

| # | Truth | Status | Evidence |
|---|-------|--------|----------|
| 1 | User can run `cargo pmcp loadtest upload --server-id <id> config.toml` and the TOML content is sent to pmcp.run via GraphQL | VERIFIED | `Upload` variant exists in `LoadtestCommand` enum with `--server-id` and `path` args; dispatches to `upload::execute()`; which calls `graphql::upload_loadtest_config()` |
| 2 | User sees a clear, actionable error when the TOML file is missing, malformed, or contains no scenarios | VERIFIED | `upload.rs` lines 27-49: file read error via `with_context`, validation failure via `LoadTestConfig::from_toml()` with 4-line fix guidance printed to stderr |
| 3 | User sees the uploaded config's identifier and version echoed back on success | VERIFIED | `upload.rs` lines 87-92: `result.config_id` and `result.version` printed in success branch |
| 4 | User sees next-steps guidance pointing to the pmcp.run dashboard after a successful upload | VERIFIED | `upload.rs` lines 94-103: "Next steps:" block with dashboard URL, cloud trigger hint, and local run alternative |
| 5 | Upload reuses the same OAuth/client-credentials auth flow as `cargo pmcp test upload` with no additional login | VERIFIED | `upload.rs` line 65: `auth::get_credentials().await?`; `auth.rs` line 284: `pub async fn get_credentials()` is the shared OAuth entry point |
| 6 | Upload sends config content, format (toml), config name, and server association via GraphQL mutation | VERIFIED | `graphql.rs` lines 1203-1249: `upload_loadtest_config()` sends `serverId`, `name`, `description`, `content`, `format` as GraphQL variables; `upload.rs` line 76 hardcodes `"toml"` |
| 7 | Config file is parsed via `LoadTestConfig::from_toml()` and validated (valid TOML, has scenarios, weights > 0) before upload | VERIFIED | `upload.rs` line 35: `LoadTestConfig::from_toml(&content)` called before auth (fail-fast pattern); `config.rs` line 176-178 confirms `from_toml` calls `validate()` |
| 8 | Validation errors include the specific reason and guidance on how to fix the config | VERIFIED | `upload.rs` lines 36-48: error reason from `e` (the `LoadTestError`), plus four specific fix instructions printed to stderr |

**Score:** 8/8 truths verified

---

### Required Artifacts

| Artifact | Expected | Status | Details |
|----------|----------|--------|---------|
| `cargo-pmcp/src/deployment/targets/pmcp_run/graphql.rs` | `upload_loadtest_config()` GraphQL mutation function | VERIFIED | Function at line 1203; `UploadLoadtestConfigResult` struct at line 1196; inner response struct at line 1241; all four documented patterns confirmed |
| `cargo-pmcp/src/commands/loadtest/upload.rs` | Complete upload command implementation with validation, auth, upload, and display | VERIFIED | 133 lines; contains `LoadTestConfig::from_toml`, `get_credentials`, `upload_loadtest_config`, "Next steps" — all substantive |
| `cargo-pmcp/src/commands/loadtest/mod.rs` | `Upload` variant in `LoadtestCommand` enum with CLI args | VERIFIED | `mod upload;` at line 8; `Upload` variant at line 69; match arm dispatch at lines 110-118 |

---

### Key Link Verification

| From | To | Via | Status | Details |
|------|----|-----|--------|---------|
| `commands/loadtest/upload.rs` | `deployment/targets/pmcp_run/graphql.rs` | `graphql::upload_loadtest_config()` call | WIRED | `upload.rs` line 70: `graphql::upload_loadtest_config(...)` called with all required arguments |
| `commands/loadtest/upload.rs` | `deployment/targets/pmcp_run/auth.rs` | `auth::get_credentials()` call | WIRED | `upload.rs` line 65: `auth::get_credentials().await?`; `credentials.access_token` field used at line 71 (field confirmed at `auth.rs` line 251) |
| `commands/loadtest/upload.rs` | `loadtest/config.rs` | `LoadTestConfig::from_toml()` for TOML validation | WIRED | `upload.rs` line 8: `use cargo_pmcp::loadtest::config::LoadTestConfig`; line 35: `LoadTestConfig::from_toml(&content)` called |
| `commands/loadtest/mod.rs` | `commands/loadtest/upload.rs` | `upload::execute()` dispatch from `LoadtestCommand::Upload` match arm | WIRED | `mod.rs` line 8: `mod upload;`; lines 110-118: match arm calls `upload::execute(server_id, path, name, description)` |

---

### Requirements Coverage

| Requirement | Source Plan | Description | Status | Evidence |
|-------------|------------|-------------|--------|----------|
| CLI-01 | 25-01, 25-02 | User can run `cargo pmcp loadtest upload` with `--server-id` and TOML path | SATISFIED | `Upload` variant in `LoadtestCommand` with `#[arg(long)] server_id: String` and `#[arg(required = true)] path: PathBuf` |
| CLI-02 | 25-01, 25-02 | User receives clear error if TOML config is invalid or has no scenarios | SATISFIED | Validation error path in `upload.rs` lines 35-49 with 4 specific fix instructions |
| CLI-03 | 25-01, 25-02 | User sees upload success with config identifier and version from pmcp.run | SATISFIED | Success branch prints `result.config_id` and `result.version` from GraphQL response |
| CLI-04 | 25-01, 25-02 | User sees next steps guidance (view on pmcp.run dashboard, trigger remote run) | SATISFIED | "Next steps:" block with dashboard URL, cloud trigger mention, and local run alternative |
| UPLD-01 | 25-01, 25-02 | Loadtest TOML config content is uploaded via GraphQL mutation to pmcp.run | SATISFIED | `upload_loadtest_config()` mutation function in `graphql.rs` using `execute_graphql()` |
| UPLD-02 | 25-01, 25-02 | Upload reuses existing pmcp.run auth (OAuth, client credentials, access token) | SATISFIED | `auth::get_credentials()` call in `upload.rs`; same function used by test upload |
| UPLD-03 | 25-01, 25-02 | Upload sends config content, format, name, and server association | SATISFIED | GraphQL variables include `serverId`, `name`, `description`, `content`, `format` (hardcoded `"toml"`) |
| VALD-01 | 25-01, 25-02 | Config file is parsed and validated before upload (valid TOML, has scenarios) | SATISFIED | `LoadTestConfig::from_toml(&content)` called before auth at `upload.rs` line 35 |
| VALD-02 | 25-01, 25-02 | User receives actionable error messages for invalid configs | SATISFIED | Error branch prints specific reason plus 4 fix instructions (TOML syntax, `[settings]` block, `[[scenario]]` block, `init` command hint) |

All 9 requirements assigned to Phase 25 in REQUIREMENTS.md are satisfied. No orphaned requirements found — REQUIREMENTS.md traceability table maps all 9 IDs exclusively to Phase 25.

---

### Anti-Patterns Found

| File | Line | Pattern | Severity | Impact |
|------|------|---------|----------|--------|
| — | — | None detected | — | — |

No TODO/FIXME/HACK/PLACEHOLDER comments found. No empty return stubs. No console-log-only handlers. No form handlers that only call `preventDefault`. All match arms produce real side effects.

---

### Human Verification Required

#### 1. Validation Fast-Fail Before Auth

**Test:** Create an invalid TOML file (e.g., `bad.toml` with `[bad]` only) and run `cargo pmcp loadtest upload --server-id any123 bad.toml`
**Expected:** Error message printed immediately with TOML fix guidance; NO OAuth browser window or credential prompt appears
**Why human:** The code path exists and the validate-before-auth order is confirmed in source, but the actual terminal behavior (no auth prompt) requires a live run to confirm the OAuth flow is not triggered on the error branch

#### 2. Successful End-to-End Upload

**Test:** With a valid pmcp.run account and server ID, run `cargo pmcp loadtest upload --server-id <real-id> .pmcp/loadtest.toml`
**Expected:** Auth succeeds silently (reusing cached credentials), upload completes, output shows config ID and version number, "Next steps:" block appears with the correct dashboard URL
**Why human:** Requires live pmcp.run backend; the `uploadLoadtestConfig` GraphQL mutation does not exist in any test fixture and cannot be exercised without the real API endpoint

---

### Build Quality Gates

| Gate | Result |
|------|--------|
| `cargo check` | PASSED — `Finished dev profile` with 0 errors |
| `cargo fmt --check` | PASSED — no output (clean) |
| `cargo clippy -- -D warnings` | PASSED — `Finished dev profile` with 0 warnings |
| `cargo test` | PASSED — 7 unit tests + 2 doc-tests = 9 total, all passed |

Commit hashes documented in SUMMARY files are present in git history:
- `77c6bf3` — feat(25-01): add upload_loadtest_config() GraphQL mutation
- `d87002a` — feat(25-01): create loadtest upload command implementation
- `3c24742` — feat(25-01): wire Upload variant into LoadtestCommand enum
- `d922eee` — fix(25-02): add missing request_interval_ms to property tests

---

### Gaps Summary

No gaps. All 8 observable truths verified, all 3 required artifacts exist and are substantive and wired, all 4 key links confirmed present, all 9 requirement IDs satisfied with code evidence. Build compiles clean with zero clippy warnings and all tests passing.

---

_Verified: 2026-02-28T16:00:00Z_
_Verifier: Claude (gsd-verifier)_
